top of page

Insurance Says My Roof Is Bad? What to Do Next in Florida

1 day ago
5 min read

If insurance says your roof is bad, or you got a letter saying you need a new roof, the first question is how they decided that. More companies now use a satellite photo or other aerial image when they review a policy. Those pictures can be useful. They can also be wrong.

A homeowner in Rio Rico, Arizona, found that out in 2026. AAA Insurance sent her a letter saying aerial images showed her four-year-old roof was damaged, and it threatened not to renew her policy unless she had it repaired. A Nov. 13, 2026, report by KVOA News 4 Tucson said the company had relied on a blurry satellite image that falsely flagged the roof as damaged. She called eight roofing companies: three gave estimates as high as $15,000, and five said no repairs were needed. AAA told her it would not consider verbal or written roofing inspections. It wanted up-close, comprehensive photos of the whole roof, taken by her or by someone she hired. After she sent those photos, AAA lifted the non-renewal and said the policy was set to renew on January 30, 2027. She still switched insurers.

If you just got a letter like that, you are not alone. You do not have to climb on your roof, or rush into a new one, before you understand what the insurer actually saw.

Why did insurance use a satellite photo of my roof?

Some homeowners insurance companies already use drone, aircraft, and satellite images to review roofs before they renew a policy. KVOA reported that this has become common practice for some companies. A Nov. 5, 2026, explainer from Home Policy Atlas says an insurer may look at a house from above when you apply or when a policy is coming up for renewal. Those pictures can help spot missing shingles, tree limbs, or debris, but they can also be wrong. Satellite photos may miss fine details because of resolution, shadows, tree cover, or the date the image was taken. An older image can make a repaired roof look damaged.

On Nov. 3, 2026, Insurtech Insights reported that Matter Intelligence has a space-based tool that uses spectral sensing and AI to assess residential roof condition for insurers. The company said it completed a proof of concept with one of the five largest U.S. property and casualty insurers, and plans to go live with insurers in the first quarter of 2027. That is the company’s description of its product, not proof that every insurer already uses it.

Insurance company says I need a new roof. Do I have to replace it?

Not automatically. First confirm what the insurer flagged, when the image was taken, and what evidence it will accept. If the condition is unclear, get a qualified assessment before you commit to major work, and keep the deadline in view.

What should I do if I get a roof non-renewal letter in Florida?

  1. Read the letter carefully. Note the reason, what they want, how to respond, and the deadline. Keep the whole letter.

  2. Ask which image they used, and when it was taken. Ask what they think they saw and what evidence they will consider. You can also ask for a copy of the image. Whether they have to provide it depends on your state.

  3. Get current, up-close documentation. Do not climb onto the roof to take photos yourself. A qualified inspector can document the whole roof with dated, close-up photos. If you already had work done, gather invoices or completion records too.

  4. Respond in writing by the deadline. Send the photos and any report through the channel the letter names, and keep a copy. Updated evidence does not guarantee that a non-renewal will be withdrawn. If the deadline is close, talk with your agent about backup coverage.

  5. Talk to your agent. Your agent can help you understand what this company will accept and what a new company might ask for.

Requirements vary by company. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation requires a four-point inspection from a Florida-licensed inspector for applications on homes more than 20 years old. For older roofs, it also requires a licensed inspector to check for visible damage or deterioration, plus documentation that the roof has at least five years of remaining useful life. That threshold is 25 years for soft roofs such as shingles, and 50 years for hard roofs such as tile, metal, or concrete. Those rules are about eligibility and roof age, not satellite photos. If your letter is from Citizens and asks for a specific roof form, tell us that when you call. HighMark also serves South Georgia, where each carrier sets its own rules. Ask your agent which documents you need.

How a 4-point inspection can help

HighMark Inspections, based in Lake City, Florida, inspects homes across North Florida and South Georgia. A 4-point inspection is a limited insurance inspection of the roof, electrical, plumbing, and HVAC, with photos of condition, age, and type. If your agent also wants a wind mitigation report, the Insurance Combo packages both. We can provide clear, up-close photos to include with your response. We cannot promise that your insurer will accept our report, lift a non-renewal, or keep your policy. Ask your agent whether the photos and report will meet what the letter requires.

Pricing, as listed on our Pricing and Services page:

  • 4-point inspection, stand-alone: $150. Add $25 for homes over 3,000 square feet, or $50 for homes over 4,000 square feet.

  • Insurance Combo (4-point and wind mitigation): $300, with the same size charges.

  • Wind mitigation inspection, stand-alone: $175.

Got a letter about your roof? Book a 4-point inspection or the Insurance Combo at HighMarkInspections.com and get clear, up-close photos to send your insurer. Or call or text 386-361-8040.

FAQ

Insurance says my roof is bad. What should I do first?

Read the letter and note the deadline. Ask which image they used, when it was taken, and what evidence they will consider. Then get current, up-close photos. Do not climb on the roof yourself.

Can my insurance company use a satellite photo of my roof?

Yes, some companies already use satellite, aircraft, or drone images when they review a policy. A photo can raise a question. It does not automatically prove the current condition of the roof.

My insurance company says I need a new roof. Do I have to replace it right away?

Not automatically. First confirm what they flagged, when the image was taken, and what evidence they will accept. If the condition is unclear, get a qualified assessment before major work, and keep the deadline in view.

I got a roof non-renewal letter in Florida. What happens next?

Follow the letter and respond by the deadline. Ask which image was used, get current documentation, and talk with your agent. Rules vary by insurer. Citizens has its own inspection requirements for older homes and older roofs, which are separate from a satellite-photo flag.

Will a HighMark 4-point inspection reverse a non-renewal?

No report can guarantee that. We can document the roof with current, up-close photos and a clear 4-point or insurance report. Your insurer decides what it will accept.

Insurance requirements and acceptance of reports vary by insurer, property, and state. This post is general information, not insurance advice. Confirm details with your licensed insurance agent.

CONTACT US

(386) 361-8040

SOCIAL

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube

HOURS OPEN:

Mon-Fri: 8:00am-6:00pm Sat:8:00am-1:00pm      

SERVICE AREA 

Lake City, FL | LiveOak, FL | Fort White, FL | High Springs, FL | Branford, FL | Wellborn, FL | O'Brien, FL | Macclenny, FL | Five Points, FL | Lake Butler, FL | Raiford, FL | Sanderson, FL | Jasper, FL | Alachua, FL | Ocala, FL | Newberry, FL | Jacksonville, FL | Gainesville, FL

HighMarkInspections, LLC Logo

We inspect commercial and residential properties in Lake City, FL, and all surrounding areas. We would be honored to inspect your home or business since we're going to be neighbors. 

This website was built by InterNACHI's Official Vendor for website designs www.inspectorwebsitebuilder.com.

bottom of page